academic-rebuttal

Use when an author has received peer-review comments and scores for an academic paper and needs to diagnose underlying reviewer concerns, decide whether a rebuttal is worthwhile, plan rebuttal experiments, or prepare evidence-grounded response material and revision plans for the author to review and finalize. Produces author-review material, never submission-ready rebuttals; venue generative-AI policies must be checked before use. Never fabricate results, reviewer intent, citations, or manuscript locations.